There is increasing pressure and antitrust focus on the “right to repair,” as most recently highlighted by the news (opens in a new tab) that McDonald’s may now use outside vendors to fix its broken ice cream machines.
In general, the “right to repair” concerns the ability of purchasers of equipment to effect repairs on that equipment themselves, utilizing whatever parts or services such purchasers deem most effective and efficient. In recent years, original equipment manufacturers (“OEMs”) across a wide range of industries, from automakers to consumer electronics, have adopted restrictions limiting both purchasers’ and independent service providers’ (“ISOs”) ability to repair equipment without the OEM or its authorized dealers. The right to repair movement, which includes a significant legislative campaign (opens in a new tab), seeks to end these restraints and promote fair competition in repair-related aftermarkets.
The seminal antitrust case in this space is a 1992 Supreme Court decision involving Kodak printers. Eastman Kodak Co. v. Image Tech. Servs., 509 U.S. 451 (1992) (opens in a new tab). There, ISOs alleged that Kodak, in an effort to maintain dominance over the sale of aftermarket parts and services for its printers, unlawfully tied the sale of replacement parts to repairs by Kodak, cut off ISOs’ access to alternative parts, and pressured Kodak equipment owners and part distributors not to sell to ISOs.
In reversing summary judgment for Kodak, the Supreme Court held that, even if an OEM lacks market power in the original product market (i.e., the foremarket for printers), it can be liable where it abuses its market power through anticompetitive conduct in the aftermarket (i.e., repairs for Kodak printers). In particular, the Court found that due to the high cost of printers, purchasers were “locked-in” to their purchases in the foremarket and lacked sufficient information to reliably estimate total lifecycle costs in choosing between competing printers.
Following the 1992 Eastman Kodak decision, attempts by OEMs to monopolize aftermarkets ceased for a time. OEMs, however, began using creative strategies involving limitations on OEM warranty obligations and claimed IP rights to reassert their dominance of aftermarkets. To combat consumer exploitation in repair aftermarkets, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) began an in-depth inquiry into how OEMs were systematically exploiting consumers by extracting monopoly rents in repair aftermarkets.
Following public hearings and the receipt of myriad public submissions, the FTC published its “Nixing the Fix (opens in a new tab)” report. The report determined that OEMs were restricting independent service and repairs through a variety of means including physical restrictions, limiting access to parts or repair manuals, disparaging non-OEM competitors, embedding software to force consumers to use the OEM, and steering or tying parts and services. Shortly after the report was issued, President Biden issued an Executive Order on Promoting Competition in the American Economy (opens in a new tab), which directed the Chair of the FTC to address “unfair anticompetitive restrictions on third-party repair or self-repair of items.”
These government actions triggered a new wave of private litigation. In one case, a class of farmers have alleged that farm equipment manufacturing giant, Deere and Co., violated the antitrust laws by withholding software tools and resources needed to independently repair John Deere tractors and farm equipment. In re Deere & Co. Repair Servs. Antitrust Litig., MDL 3030 (N.D. Ill. Nov. 27, 2023) (opens in a new tab). The farmers’ claims, which survived a motion to dismiss, were buoyed by the Department of Justice, which filed an amicus brief (opens in a new tab) in support of their claims. The FTC also has begun investigating (opens in a new tab) John Deere’s repair policies.
In a similar case, a court ruled that owners of Tesla vehicles may proceed with claims alleging that Tesla unlawfully monopolized the aftermarket for Tesla repairs and parts by preventing ISOs from accessing required parts and repair tools. Lambrix v. Tesla, No. 23-cv-01145-TLT (N.D. Cal. June 17, 2024) (opens in a new tab).
And in another case, an independent servicer of aircraft engine parts sued Pratt & Whitney claiming Pratt unlawfully restricts competition for aftermarket engine repairs by restricting non-Pratt part purchases, predatory buying of available engine parts, refusing to deal with ISOs, and charging supracompetitive prices for repair manuals. Universal Turbine Parts, LLC v. Pratt & Whitney, No. 2:24-cv-02021 (E.D. Pa.) (opens in a new tab).
These cases highlight that legal activity over the right to repair will continue to heat up as the government, ISOs, and consumers assert new challenges to OEM practices. The ability of consumers to repair their vehicles and consumer electronics is one of several antitrust issues that cross the political divide and should continue to receive considerable attention from government enforcers in the new administration.