The average cost of diesel today is causing severe cost shocks across a range of industries, leading to stagnation and margin compression. If what’s past is prologue, another cartel wave may be emerging.

In late September 2026, the national average price of diesel fuel reached a record price of $6.53 per gallon and roughly $2.00 higher than prices set at the start of the year. The cause of this price spike is well-known: Iran’s disruption of tanker traffic through the Strait of Hormuz has shut in an estimated 6.7 million barrels per day of Middle East crude in August, and U.S. distillate inventories will fall below 100 million barrels this fall—for the first time since 2003—and stay below the five-year low deep into 2027.1

The price of diesel has an outsized effect on the U.S. economy, since diesel literally fuels the freight economy, affecting the cost of shipping food and goods. And now, every trucking fleet, farm operation, and manufacturer in the country is now absorbing a significant margin shock leading up to a critical fourth quarter. We have seen versions of this story before: When an entire industry’s margins collapse, there is a strong temptation for competitors to collude rather than compete through the trough.

Hard Times Make for Willing Conspirators

Economic theory suggests that a consistent triggering event for cartel formation is a significant decline in prices and profits within a particular industry. For example, the auto parts cartel, at the time deemed to be the largest cartel in history, was formed in the cauldron of the “dot com bust” and endured through the through the bankruptcies of Chrysler and General Motors. For more than a decade, auto parts suppliers had rigged bids submitted to automakers on dozens of disparate components such as wire harnesses, seat belts, radiators, and windshield wipers. The auto parts cartel only stopped operating once prosecutors started their investigations and brought criminal charges against several companies and their executives. Forty-six companies eventually pleaded guilty and paid roughly $2.9 billion in criminal fines, while 32 of their executives went to prison.2

The financial crisis several years later produced another flurry of cartel activity. Most notably, when interbank funding froze in 2007 and 2008, the banks on the LIBOR panel began submitting figures designed to conceal their financial condition, since the publicly disclosed LIBOR submissions were supposed to reflect rates that the banks would pay to borrow certain currencies for certain periods of time in the London interbank market. Following The Wall Street Journal’s May 2008 analysis of how LIBOR rates had become divorced from other economic indicators, a flurry of government investigation and private lawsuits resulted in the panel banks collectively paying more than $9 billion in penalties.3 LIBOR was hardly an isolated incident. Contemporaneous investigations and lawsuits accused traders at major dealers for manipulating FX rates, Euribor, Euroyen TIBOR, and the ISDAfix swap benchmark. Further lawsuits alleged that dealers blocked exchange trading of interest rate, colluded in Treasury auctions and secondary trading, and fixed prices for supranational, sovereign and agency bonds and Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac bonds.

The Particular Problem of Fuel and Transportation: The Air Cargo Cartel

Transportation costs affect a wide range of industries across the economy and there is a ready precedent for what happens when fuel costs climb significantly in the cargo sector. When jet fuel costs climbed after 2000, the world’s airlines agreed to a fixed “fuel surcharge.” As a result of its investigation, the U.S. Department of Justice found that these surcharges rose “by as much as 1,000 percent during the conspiracy, far outpacing any percentage increases in fuel costs.”4 The final tally on the air cargo cartel was staggering, even by today’s standards: 22 airlines and 21 executives were charged with criminally violating U.S. antitrust law, resulting in more $1.8 billion in criminal fines and prison sentences for eight executive.5

Fast forward to today: during the current quarter, nearly every carrier, broker, and logistics firm in America is either instituting or raising a diesel surcharge. As customers inevitably push back against the increased costs of shipping goods, will history repeat itself? And, as the financial impact of higher fuel prices reduce margins throughout the economy, could high diesel prices fuel a recession that result in cartel agreements in other industries?

*          *          *          *

Many cartels have been disrupted by leniency programs operated by the Department of Justice and other enforcers across the globe, most notably by the Directorate General for Competition at the European Commission. But leniency applications are down from their heights a decade or two ago and there has been a growing concurrence in the business community that the many benefits of leniency—amnesty from criminal prosecution, as well as from criminal and civil fines (depending on the jurisdiction)—are not worth the costs subsequently extracted by civil class action litigation. To the extent that cartels do in fact form in the wake of spiraling fuel costs, it is unclear whether enforcers, who have heavily relied on the enticements offered by their leniency programs to attract defections from cartels, are ready for it.

Notes

  1. U.S. Energy Information Administration, Gasoline and Diesel Fuel Update (Oct. 14, 2026), https://www.eia.gov/petroleum/gasdiesel/ (opens in a new tab); U.S. Energy Information Administration, Short-Term Energy Outlook (Sept. 9, 2026), https://www.eia.gov/outlooks/steo/pdf/steo_full.pdf (opens in a new tab); U.S. Energy Information Administration, Press Release (Sept. 9, 2026), https://www.eia.gov/pressroom/releases/press592.php (opens in a new tab). ↩
  2. Press Release, U.S. Department of Justice, Extradited Former Automotive Parts Executive Pleads Guilty to Antitrust Charge (Mar. 3, 2020), https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/extradited-former-automotive-parts-executive-pleads-guilty-antitrust-charge (opens in a new tab). ↩
  3. Understanding the Libor Scandal, Council on Foreign Relations, https://www.cfr.org/backgrounders/understanding-libor-scandal (opens in a new tab). ↩
  4. CBS News, 21 Airlines Fined For Fixing Passenger, Cargo Fees (Mar. 5, 2011) https://www.cbsnews.com/losangeles/news/21-airlines-fined-for-fixing-passenger-cargo-fees/ (opens in a new tab) ↩
  5. Press Release, U.S. Department of Justice, Extradited Former Air Cargo Executive Pleads Guilty to Participating in Worldwide Price-Fixing Conspiracy, https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/extradited-former-air-cargo-executive-pleads-guilty-participating-worldwide-price-fixing (opens in a new tab). ↩